Trane vs. Goodman Comparison 2024: Which Is Best?

Trane vs. Goodman At a Glance

Trane and Goodman are popular brands that manufacture various products that provide solutions for various heating and cooling needs. Here’s a quick explanation about both HVAC companies.

Trane: Company Overview

Trane, founded in 1885, is a global HVAC leader with a stellar reputation for energy-efficient solutions. It offers a wide range of top-tier products spanning residential, commercial, and industrial applications, including air conditioners, heat pumps, and air quality solutions.

Trane’s Products & Services

• Cooling Systems:
  Trane designs various air conditioning systems suited for effective cooling in residential and business settings.
• Heat Transfer Pumps:
  Heat pumps use the transfer of indoor-outdoor heat to provide heating and cooling capabilities, offering energy-efficient solutions for maintaining comfortable inside temperatures.
• Configurations without Ductwork:
  Mini-split systems without ductwork provide a flexible and efficient way to heat and cool particular building areas without using complex ducting.
• Air Handlers:
  These units work with your HVAC system to circulate conditioned air throughout the space, contributing to consistent comfort.
• Heating Units:
  Trane furnaces are designed to meet the heating needs of homes and commercial buildings. They come in energy-efficient models with different performance levels and features.

Pros

• Offers HVAC units with low noise levels
• Incorporates advanced technologies for better performance
• Has a reputation for quality & durability
• Has an extensive network of professional dealers for proper installation and maintenance

Cons

• Does not provide pricing information
• Limited range of product options

Goodman: Company Overview

Goodman is a trusted HVAC brand known for its reliable and affordable heating and cooling solutions. With a focus on affordability, Goodman offers a range of products, including air conditioners, heat pumps, gas furnaces, and packaged units.

The company, a part of the Daikin Group, ensures global availability through its widespread network of dealers, providing affordable and dependable options for residential needs.

Goodman’s Products & Services

• Air conditioners:
  The air conditioners made by Goodman are intended to maintain a cool indoor temperature throughout the summer. They are available in a wide range of sizes and degrees of efficiency. 
• Heat Pumps:
  By transporting heat from the inside to the outdoors, Goodman heat pumps can heat and cool spaces. These climate control choices are flexible and offer energy-efficient alternatives.
• Gas furnaces:
  Goodman provides a selection of gas furnaces made to increase the energy economy while providing continuous warmth.
• Air cleaners and filtration:
  Goodman helps to create healthier indoor environments by removing dust, allergies, and toxins from the air, offering air cleaners and filtration systems.
• UV Air Purifiers:
  UV air purifiers use ultraviolet light to destroy allergens and pathogens in the air, improving indoor air quality and making living spaces cleaner.
• Packaged Units:
  Goodman provides gas/electric and heat pump packaged systems. These are ideal for homes with little inside space since they integrate heating and cooling elements into a single outside unit.

Pros

• Offers budget-friendly options with essential features
• Products are energy-efficient to save utility costs
• Features a unique design that redefines durability in the heating and cooling industry
• Offers product replacement with its warranty

Cons

• Some models may have higher noise levels
• Limited advanced features

Trane vs. Goodman: Detailed Comparison

Both Trane and Goodman produce high-quality HVAC systems. Thus, choosing any of these options ensures a quality system is installed in your home.

The following factors have been taken into consideration when we compared these companies.

Design

The sleek and elegant design of Trane units reflects a modern style that works well in various interior situations. This design decision enhances their aesthetic appeal and adaptability to various settings.

On the other hand, Goodman HVAC systems stand out for their minimalist design, which values simplicity above complex visuals. Those who like a simple, unassuming appearance for their HVAC equipment may find this method particularly appealing.

Build Quality And Durability

Both Trane and Goodman HVAC systems, when properly installed and regularly maintained, are designed to last between 15 to 20 years. However, the age range may differ from person to person, depending on the usage. Nonetheless, both companies aim to provide durable products that offer customers a substantial lifespan for their investment.

Performance

Trane is renowned for delivering high-performance HVAC systems. Their units often feature advanced technologies for energy efficiency and precise climate control.

On the other hand, Goodman HVAC systems offer reliable performance with a focus on cost-effectiveness. While they may have slightly fewer advanced features, they are known for providing solid and consistent performance.

Noise Levels

Trane air conditioners and heaters are known for operating quietly. Trane puts effort into making them produce less noise by using unique technologies. This feature helps make your indoor environment quieter and more comfortable.

On the other hand, while generally reliable, Goodman systems may not prioritize low noise levels to the same extent as Trane. Some Goodman models may operate at a consistent, single speed, which can be less flexible in adjusting noise levels based on varying demands.

Energy Efficiency

Trane HVAC systems are super-efficient, with SEER ratings ranging from 14 to 22. The higher the SEER rating, the more efficient the product is. Most Trane products go up to 22, showing they are top-notch when it comes to saving energy.

Goodman HVAC systems are also designed to be energy-efficient, with competitive SEER ratings. While they might not hit high SEER numbers like Trane’s premium units, Goodman focuses on offering budget-friendly solutions that save energy. The SEER rating ranges from 13 to 24.5.

Installation

Trane recommends installation by certified technicians, often through their Comfort Specialist program. These technicians are trained to ensure proper installation, maximizing the efficiency and longevity of the HVAC system. Trane’s commitment to installation quality is reflected in its stringent technician requirements.

While also recommending professional installation, Goodman typically provides flexibility in choosing certified HVAC technicians. This approach allows consumers to select technicians with relevant certifications, ensuring competent installation and future maintenance.

Warranty

Trane typically offers a range of warranty options depending on the specific product and system components. Standard warranties often include a 10-year limited warranty on the compressor and a 10-year limited warranty on the outdoor coil. 

In most cases, this warranty lasts five years, but the length of coverage may change depending on the product. Extended warranty options may be available for additional coverage.

Goodman air conditioners come with a standard 5-year parts limited warranty, but registering your unit under specific conditions extends it to a 10-year parts limited warranty. This enhanced coverage includes replacement parts for defects due to workmanship or materials. Some models may also qualify for a 10-year unit replacement limited warranty and a lifetime compressor limited warranty.

Maintenance And Repairs

Properly maintaining HVAC systems is essential for maintaining their lifespan. Trane goes above and beyond by providing maintenance support that meets its high-quality standards, ensuring ongoing peak performance. 

The endurance of Goodman units, however, requires regular maintenance. You must commit to suggested maintenance procedures to prolong the lifespan of Goodman systems.

Features & Capacities

Trane excels in integrating advanced technology, offering energy-saving features and smart thermostats for efficient HVAC systems. It provides features like ComfortLink Technology, Variable Speed Technology, Quiet Operation, High Efficiency, etc. It often has high cooling and heating capacities, suitable for diverse climates.

On the other hand, Goodman is a trusted HVAC brand that provides reliable performance at a more affordable price point. You can expect features such as Smart Speed, ComfortBridge, Smart Coil Technologies, Comfort Alert Diagnostics, and the CoolCloud HVAC app with Goodman air conditioners. Moreover, the company offers cost-effective capacities for effective heating and cooling. 

Note: To know more about the features, we advise you to carefully read the product description in your contract.

Pricing & Financing Options

Neither Trane nor Goodman provide pricing details on their websites. However, Trane does share average costs for installing and replacing air conditioners, ranging from $3,400 to $20,000. 

Additionally, Trane offers a convenient “System Recommendation Tool” on its website. By entering your requirements and zip code, the tool provides recommendations for Trane systems, suggests nearby dealer stores, and offers average cost estimates. This tool can be useful for obtaining an approximate idea of the price range for a new Trane system.

Furthermore, Trane provides various financing options in collaboration with its dealers. Presently, Trane offers a financing option called the “Special Financing Offer,” which features 0% APR for 60 months on your purchase.

Goodman also provides financing options through its local, independent dealers. Its website says the financing options include low monthly payments with zero down payment. 

Note: We advise you to contact Trane and Goodman dealers in your area to understand the exact pricing and financing options available.

Customer Support & Reviews

Trane offers support in various ways, such as a live chat feature, customer support lines, FAQs, and specially curated HVAC guides for its customers. However, despite these options, Trane has received ratings below average at 1.07/5 on BBB. The majority of reviews indicate complaints about delayed responses from customer support representatives. 

Customers have mentioned difficulties in contacting the support team via phone, leading them to emailing and waiting for a response. The company should address such issues to preserve the positive customer experience associated with Trane’s reputation. 

On the other hand, Goodman offers assistance to customers through various channels, such as online forms, live chat, and FAQs, ensuring prompt help is readily accessible. The customer ratings across the web reflect that the company has received a subpar rating. 

Some of the reviews highlight the swift responsiveness of the customer service team but express dissatisfaction with the professionalism of the local representatives. However, customers commend Goodman for its superior condensers, enhancing their overall experience. So, the company must take appropriate measures to address and resolve these issues.

Environmental Sustainability

Trane’s sustainability strategy has three prime objectives– energy efficiency, carbon reduction, and responsible manufacturing. In 2022, the company was awarded rank 1 in sustainability and brand affinity in HVACs by the Green Builder Media. 

Trane utilizes the R410-A refrigerant to prioritize safety, which is considered safer than the R-22 alternative. Moreover, Trane Technologies, the parent company of Trane, has launched a “Gigaton Challenge.” Under this, they aim to reduce one gigaton carbon footprint of their customers by 2030. 

Similarly, Goodman also aims to make eco-consciousness accessible to a broader audience. The company has achieved ISO 14001:2015 accreditation, which internationally represents the standards for environmental management systems. As per Goodman, they have become the first company in the world to apply R-32 refrigerant in their air conditioners. 

Compared to R410-A, which many companies, including Trane widely use, R-32 has a one-third lower global warming potential. According to Goodman, if all R410-A refrigerants were replaced with R-32, the Global Warming Impact could be reduced by 19% by 2030!

Which One Is Better, Goodman Or Trane?

Trane and Goodman are known for making good HVAC systems. People like Trane because it has a history of being dependable and lasts a long time. Goodman also has loyal customers because it works hard to make reliable and efficient products.

Moreover, it’s advisable to carefully assess your specific needs, budget, and preferences to determine if Trane or Goodman HVAC systems align with your requirements. Consulting with HVAC professionals can help you make an informed decision for your home or business.